Leading from Alongside, Rather Than Out in Front: Non-Positional Ways of Being a Teacher Leader

  • Embracing critical “behind the scenes” roles: When Adam* began implementing Standards Based Grading (SBG) into his physics classes, he frequently talked with his colleagues about benefits he saw in his students’ learning and motivation. As other teachers expressed interest, Adam met with them one-on-one to answer questions, work out logistics, draft letters to parents, and address students’ question and concerns about this new grading system. Soon, seven other teachers in his department were using SBG, including Adam’s department chair, Susan, who organized a weekly meeting of teachers using SBG and advocated directly to the principal about technical issues with the school’s online grading system.
    As department chair, Susan took on the more visible, and traditional, leadership role — “out in front” of the weekly meetings, and liaising with the principal. Still, Adam’s own behind-the-scenes role was instrumental in bringing others on board with SBG and helping to work out the kinks. As he describes, his “behind the scenes” leadership style — initiating one-on-one conversations, generating enthusiasm for a new idea, and supporting others — is an important complement to Susan’s organization and assertiveness, and both these styles are important to the department. By embracing this quieter style of leadership, Adam plays to his strengths, advances an important initiative, and demonstrates that there is more than one way to be a leader.
  • Acting as a “first follower”: When Barbara, a special education teacher at Reagan’s* school, began advocating for regular education teachers to make their classes more inclusive of students with disabilities, many teachers were skeptical and frustrated. Reagan was not naive about the work needed to modify her biology class to accommodate a wide range of learners, so she began to work closely with Barbara to better meet her students’ needs. The two met regularly, often after school, to discuss upcoming units in the biology curriculum, identify key concepts that all students — regardless of ability — should learn, and then modify activities and develop guided notes to focus on these core concepts. Reagan also attended voluntary workshops that Barbara offered on behavior intervention and supports. Soon, Reagan was learning to modify her instructional materials more efficiently on her own, and Barbara was able to offer more direct support to individual students.
    By embracing Barbara’s vision of an inclusive classroom, Reagan not only saw improvement in her students’ learning, she also developed new teaching skills. But just as importantly, as the first science teacher to get behind Barbara’s idea, Reagan gained a new collaborator, and helped to demonstrate to other teachers how inclusion can work in a mainstream classroom. Derek Silver’s TED Talk calls a first follower “an underappreciated form of leadership.” By partnering with Barbara on inclusive teaching practices, Reagan modeled how this vision was achievable, and why it was in the best interest of her students.
  • Valuing collaborative products over individual ideas: In her fifth year of teaching, Katherine* moved to a new school where she began working with a PLC of other chemistry teachers. Katherine did not always agree with the pacing or priorities of her new chemistry curriculum, so she raised questions to the other teachers, or suggested new ideas for assessment or student-centered explorations. Many of her ideas were not adopted by her PLC; instead the majority agreed to modify plans they had used in previous years rather than creating something brand-new. But since Katherine’s goal was to influence the chemistry curriculum in the long run, rather than do her own thing in her classroom, she continued to offer ideas while working with her colleagues rather than separate from them. As a result, she’s finding that remaining open to her colleagues’ ideas creates opportunities for them, in turn, to accept her own ideas.
    As she describes, “Part of being a teacher leader is valuing group products and processes over your own opinions or ways of doing things. If the group can produce something that everyone feels proud of, then the relationships become stronger and everyone’s work in their classroom improves.” For Katherine, teacher leadership does not mean imposing ideas on others. Instead, it involves a give-and-take of ideas among colleagues to strengthen relationships and create collaborative products. She believes this kind of teacher leadership has the potential to improve teaching in her own classroom and beyond.

--

--

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Knowles Teacher Initiative

Knowles Teacher Initiative

The Knowles Teacher Initiative supports the efforts of high school mathematics and science teachers to improve education in their classrooms and beyond​.